The Ocean Bay House — boutique coastal hotel near the Great South Bay

Where to Stay This Week · Issue 01

The Ocean Bay House

A curated coastal escape near the Great South Bay

Bay Shore, Long Island

The Editorial

A boutique idea of the coast.

Reported & curated by the LI Shellfish Guide editors.

There is a quiet kind of luxury that lives in the smaller bay towns of Long Island — places where the docks creak in the evening, the oyster boats come home at dusk, and a porch light feels like an invitation. The Ocean Bay House captures that mood with the precision of a boutique, and the ease of a friend's beach house.

Tucked moments from downtown Bay Shore and a short walk to the Fire Island ferries, the property pairs weathered-wood architecture with crisp linens, woven textures, and a palette borrowed directly from the bay outside. Mornings begin with espresso on the lawn; afternoons drift toward the marina; evenings end at the fire pit, fingers wrapped around a glass of something cold.

It is the kind of place chosen by couples seeking a slow weekend, by chefs and food editors quietly slipping out from the city, and by anyone whose ideal Saturday includes a dozen oysters, a glass of Muscadet, and a long walk along the water.

The Look

In residence.

Photographed at golden hour across one long weekend on the bay.

Linen-draped boutique guest room flooded with morning light
Linen-draped boutique guest room flooded with morning light
Outdoor lounge with rattan chairs at golden hour
Outdoor lounge with rattan chairs at golden hour
Coastal breakfast spread with espresso and pastries
Coastal breakfast spread with espresso and pastries
Sunset over Great South Bay marina
Sunset over Great South Bay marina
Oyster platter on ice with mignonette and lemon
Oyster platter on ice with mignonette and lemon
Coastal interior with weathered wood and natural linens
Coastal interior with weathered wood and natural linens
Outdoor fire pit at dusk on the bay
Outdoor fire pit at dusk on the bay
Crafted cocktail with citrus garnish on a teak bar
Crafted cocktail with citrus garnish on a teak bar

Why We Love It

Six reasons it stays with you.

Boutique Coastal Atmosphere

Curated interiors of weathered oak, linen, and seafoam — a luxury that feels lived-in, not staged.

Walkable Downtown Bay Shore

Step out the door to Main Street's restaurants, wine bars, and independent shops.

Minutes from Fire Island Ferries

Spend mornings at the hotel, afternoons on the white sand of Ocean Beach or Cherry Grove.

Romantic Weekend Energy

Fire pits, soaking tubs, and quiet corners designed for two.

At the Door of Oyster Country

Direct access to Great South Bay's working farms and the heart of LI shellfish culture.

Luxury Without Pretension

Service that feels effortless, generous, and genuinely coastal — never stiff.

Ocean view at golden hour

"Some places feel less like hotels and more like discovering your own private corner of the coast."

— LI Shellfish Guide

The Itinerary

Perfect Pairings Nearby

A weekend, sketched. The places we'd send a close friend if they were checking in tonight.

Pier 95 / Captain Bill's

Waterfront Dining

Pier 95 / Captain Bill's

Bay Shore's classic raw bar — local oysters and a deck on the water.

Fire Island Ferries

Day Trip

Fire Island Ferries

A 30-minute crossing to Ocean Beach, Cherry Grove, and the Fire Island lighthouse.

Great South Bay Sunset Sail

On the Water

Great South Bay Sunset Sail

Charter sails depart Bay Shore Marina nightly through the season.

Blue Point Brewing Tap Room

After Dinner

Blue Point Brewing Tap Room

Long Island's storied craft brewery — minutes inland from the bay.

LI Oyster Farms

Shellfish Experience

LI Oyster Farms

Tour working oyster farms across the Great South Bay and the Peconics.

The Lakehouse

Cocktail Hour

The Lakehouse

Bay Shore's intimate craft-cocktail destination, walkable from the hotel.

The Coastline

At the edge of the Great South Bay.

The Ocean Bay House
Fire Island Ferries
Pier 95 / Captain Bill's
Bay Shore Marina
Great South Bay Oyster Farms
Sayville Ferry
N ↑
Great South Bay
Featured Stay
Ferries
Dining & Oysters
Marina

Featured This Week

Make a weekend of it.

Pair your stay with a Long Island oyster farm tour, a sunset on Great South Bay, and dinner at one of the bay's storied waterside rooms.